fbpx
who won the election in Israel

Who won Israel election

Israel election results 2019 – 2020

Since September 2019, the State of Israel has undergone three election campaigns and all three have ended without a clear answer to the question: who won the election? Without clear election results, the fourth election campaign is already on the horizon. This is an unprecedented situation that did not happen before in Israel and probably in any democratic country in the world.

How did it happen that a relatively stable political system was thrown into a jolt whose end was not in sight? In this article, I will explain the political structure in Israel and why we are so caught up in political turmoil in Israel.

The political structure in Israel

The natural and traditional division of Israeli politics is between three major blocs:

1. The right-wing bloc

2. The left bloc

3. Arabic parties

The right-wing bloc includes the right-wing parties, religious Zionist parties and ultra-Orthodox parties. The left-wing bloc includes the leftist parties. The Arab bloc includes four different Arab parties. This is the structure that underlies the political map in Israel. Even when parties stand up, break up, connect with other parties, this is done in the context of the basic political structure.

Occasionally opportunistic parties were formed because of a protest vote or because of a temporary political constellation, but these parties did not represent a political-ideological agenda, so at the end of the hype around them, they broke up. Over the past decade, the right-wing majority in Israel has been growing, for a number of reasons:

1. Leftist ideology failures

The biggest failure was the Oslo Accords. The Oslo Accords were born to bring peace with the Palestinian Arabs and in effect led to unprecedented bloodshed following a Palestinian Authority-led terrorist campaign established on the basis of the Oslo Accords.

2. Demographics

Jewish demographics in Israel are getting stronger, year by year, but those who lead the birth chart undoubtedly are ultra-Orthodox and religious Jews, mainly residents of Judea and Samaria. This is a process that has been going on for generations and is changing the fabric of the state of Israel.

3. Immigration to Israel

Most of the immigrants who arrived in Israel in the last few decades, and more than a million people, came mainly from Russia. Immigrants from Russia are mainly identified with right-wing parties. Another significant immigration comes from France, following the rise of anti-Semitism in France. These Jews, too, usually identify with the right.

Right-wing block structure

The right-wing bloc, also known as the National Camp, now consists of the following parties: the Likud Party, the Right Party, the Shas Party, Agudat Israel and Agudat Israel.

Likud party (United) – ליכוד

After the third elections (March 2020) the Likud is the largest party in Israel. A longstanding ideological party exists even before the establishment of the State of Israel (in a different name). The Likud party voters are very large and wide, and include various populations, from the established cities, the periphery, the religious, the ultra-Orthodox, the secular.

Benjamin Netanyahu - Israel election
Benjamin Netanyahu with Donald Trump and their wives

Benjamin Netanyahu has been leading the Likud for a long time and has served as prime minister for more than a decade (making him the prime minister who has spent the most time in the State of Israel). The Likud party has more than 100,000 members and the party holds primaries to elect its Knesset representatives.

Shas party (Six Mishna books)ש”ס

Formed mainly in the 1980s for ultra-Orthodox Jews from North Africa, but the party has become a traditional Jewish public of Moroccan, Tunisian or one of North African countries.

The party has a hard cast of voters, but about half of its voters are voters who can vote for Likud or the right-wing party and their vote for the Shas party is not guaranteed although, in all three recent election campaigns, they have shown great loyalty to the party.

The Shas Party does not hold primaries and its representatives to the Knesset are elected by the leaders of the movement (who are not sitting in the Knesset). The leader of the movement today is Rabbi Arie Deri.

Arye Deri - Shas party leader - Israel elections
Arye Deri – Shas party leader

Yahadut Ha’torah (the Jews of the Torah) – יהדות התורה

Israel election
Ya’akov Litsman – Yahadut Ha’tora leader

A very old party that existed even before the establishment of the State of Israel (then called “Agudat Israel”). A definite party of ultra-Orthodox Ashkenazi Jews.

The percentage of Yahadut Ha’torah is very high and not subject to changing moods or political fashions. This is a very disciplined public that listens to the rulings and instructions of a number of rabbis who lead this public.

Yahadut Ha’torah is a political party within Israel’s political system, but it represented a public that some opposed the Zionist movement for religious reasons.

Today, there are still a number of ultra-Orthodox religious groups who still strongly oppose Zionism, but the vast majority of these opponents take no part in the political system in Israel.

The voters of this party are not Zionist in the historical sense of the word, but they are Jews who are very loyal to the State of Israel and to the Jewish people and are an essential and integral part of the State of Israel. Yahadut Ha’torah does not hold primaries and its representatives are elected by the rabbis (the ultra-Orthodox leaders who are, of course, not sitting in the Knesset).

Yemina (right) – ימינה

The movement skeleton is based on a very old stream of Israeli politics. It rose long before the State of Israel, changed names several times, but the principles and the voting public remained essentially the same.

This is an Orthodox religious public, some very religious, some traditional. Historically, this has been a movement that has supported Zionism from the beginning.

The party holds internal primaries and its representatives to the Knesset, elected by citizens who became members of the party.

Yemina party in its current assembly is a combination of three different parties, one aimed at attracting secular right-wing members who do not want to vote for Likud or Benjamin Netanyahu.

Israel election 2020
Naftali Bennett – Yemina party leader

Israel Beitenu (Israel our home) – ישראל ביתנו

Avigdor Liberman - Israel Beitenu leader
Avigdor Liberman – Israel Beitenu leader

A sectoral party founded by Avigdor Lieberman and traditionally appeals to Russian voters, consisting mainly of Soviet-born Jews who immigrated to Israel in the early 1990s, with the disintegration of the Soviet Union.

Quite a few of the Russian immigrants who arrived in Israel were non-Jews, and are a significant part of Lieberman’s target audience.

In the last two election campaigns, Lieberman has also begun to target his campaign to Israeli-born Jews who view ultra-Orthodox Jews as a political enemy.

Lieberman’s party is dictatorial in its being and everything is determined by Avigdor Lieberman’s wishes and political whims. He appoints candidates for Knesset members. There is no neat election procedure.

Once Avigdor Lieberman has decided what his opinion is about a particular issue, party members must align with his decision, even if it is a reversal of positions. Of course, they can retire from the party, which has already happened with a number of Knesset members in the past who were part of Israel Beitenu.

The structure of the left block

The left bloc consists of several parties:

Blue and White Party – כחול לבן

The Blue and White Party is a party formed by the collaboration of a number of different parties when the glue that unites the party group is obsessive hostility to Benjamin Netanyahu.

Blue and White party - Israel elections
Blue and White Party leaders – Benny Gantz – second from the left

It is seemingly difficult to find a clear ideological line within this party and in some sense is an ideological supermarket, because it contains a number of politicians who call themselves rightists and a fair number of radical leftists and politicians in between.

In addition, it contains those that support capitalism and those who support excessive socialism.

According to quotes from party leaders and members, by its voters, by its supporters and by its political partners, this is a left-wing party that has made a great effort to position itself as a right-center party, to attract right-center voters.

The reason for the dissonance between the political essence of the party and the way it tried to position itself is because of the unpopularity of the left’s position among a large majority of the Jewish public. Therefore, in order to give themselves any chance of gaining a number of voters who would position them as a governing alternative, large leftist parties in Israel used to position themselves as central parties during an election period.

The party did not hold a primaries process and its representatives are elected by party leaders making the party representatives politically enslaved to those who appointed them.

Meretz – Labor Party – עבודה מר”צ

A union between two veteran parties, Labor and Meretz created ahead of the elections, fearing that one of the parties would not be able to pass the required blocking for parliamentary entry.

The Labor Party

The Labor Party is the reincarnation of the Central Party in the Zionist movement during the pre-State period. David Ben-Gurion, the first prime minister of the State of Israel, was the mythical leader of the Labor Party.

Two of its more familiar heads were Yitzhak Rabin and Shimon Peres. The Labor Party made up the Israeli government until 1977, which was a year of political upheaval in the State of Israel.

The Labor Party lost the election and the Likud party made up the government for the first time. The Labor Party remained the largest and most dominant party in the left bloc and in 1993 returned to power, led by Yitzhak Rabin.

The Labor Party has always had a socialist orientation but not a Communist-style.

In a long, slow and tedious process, the party slowly deteriorated until most of its voters abandoned it, convinced that it was no longer able to deliver the “goods” and become a governing alternative to the right, and moved to other leftist parties.

Amir Perez - Labor party leader - Israel election
Amir Perez – Labor party leader

Even worse, from a party that was affiliated with moderate socialism, the security of the State of Israel, and with the settlement throughout Israel, the Labor Party became a twin party of the radical leftist party, with a distinctly socialist and pro-Palestinian ideology.

Today, there is no significant ideological difference between the Knesset members of the Radical Left and the Labor Party Knesset members, which has created a natural basis for connecting the two parties.

The Meretz Party

The Meretz Party is a radical left-wing party consisting mainly of Jews who identify with the Arab-Palestinian narrative completely. If in the past this party also contained a liberal economic outlook, today its orientation is a socialist-communist one. Before the last election and even more, afterward, members of this party are considering complete political assimilation within an Arab-Jewish party.

The Arab bloc

Ha’reshima Ha’meshutefet (The joint list) – הרשימה המשותפת

The unification of four different Arab parties to one party. Only one party out of the four includes a Jewish Knesset member, a very radical leftist who, in any confrontation between Israel and the terrorist organizations in Gaza, stands with his party members, alongside the terrorist organizations, against the State of Israel.

Most members of the party supported publicly terror actions or terrorists. One of the party’s leaders, Ahmed Tibi, was a close advisor to mass murderer Yasser Arafat.

Israel election
Ahmed Auda (in the center) – Ha’reshima Ha’meshutefet leader

Some members of the party were convicted of supporting terrorism and imprisoned.

One of the party members suspected, during the Second Lebanon War, of in Lebanon in order to more accurately target missiles at Israel.

Another party member (who retired a few years ago) took part in a provocative flotilla of the Marmara ship from Turkey to the Gaza Strip.

The flotilla was organized by an organization that was in contact with terrorist organizations.

Another member of the list gave an encouraging speech to terrorists who committed suicide or other terrorist acts against Israel and paid for it in their lives. They call the soldiers of the Israeli army, murderers and war criminals, they work to bring soldiers and officers to the International Court of Justice in The Hague.

Hiba Yazabak (from the Arab party): “Salutes Shahid Samir Kuntar” – Kuntar smashed the skull of four-year-old Einat Haran in a 1979 terror attack

It is possible to continue with the list of party members, but the point is clear. The members of the four parties support terrorism against Israel. They are against the State of Israel as a Jewish state and their first goal is to make Israel “the state of all its citizens”, a laundered code name intended to hide the real purpose and is to eliminate the State of Israel as a Jewish state

Ahmed Tibi (the Arab party): “No greater value than Shahada (death for Allah)”

They want to promote the “right of return” of millions of Arabs into the territory of Israel and its transformation into an Arab-Islamic state as the end goal.

Despite repeated attempts by the Knesset Election Commission to disqualify one of the three parties that stood out even more in its extreme, the Supreme Court, in a series of scandalous rulings, repeatedly reversed the decisions of the Knesset committees over the years, allowing terrorist supporters to contest and be elected to the Knesset.

Due to their actions against the State of Israel, their support for terrorism (ie the indiscriminate murder of Jews in Israel) and their aim to eliminate the State of Israel, this party is seen as illegitimate, although it is elected by an overwhelming majority of Israeli Arabs. Therefore, no Israeli politician who wants political life, dare to cooperate with them.

Why was the political plunder in Israel created?

In general, the right-wing bloc is growth over the years, for a number of reasons:

1. Demographics

The demographic of the ultra-Orthodox and religious is much stronger. An ultra-Orthodox woman gives birth to an average of 7.1 children. Religious (non-ultra-Orthodox) woman, 4 children and secular woman 3.2 children.

2. Immigration

Every year in recent years tens of thousands of Jews come from Russia, France, the United States and other countries. The political tendency of most immigrants is right.

3. Ideology failure

The Oslo agreements signed with the Palestinian Arabs and the catastrophes that followed caused many to sober up with the left’s illusions of peace and false promises.

Why Netanyahu has failed to form a government three times?

The short answer is the same answer in the three cases: Avigdor Lieberman.

Avigdor Lieberman is a very veteran politician who began his career in Israeli politics decades ago, in the Likud party, as a political advisor to Benjamin Netanyahu, and later on in his political work with Benjamin Netanyahu in various positions.

He has held a long line of positions in the Likud governments. At one point he retired from the Likud, formed a party and ran independently. But even when Lieberman ran alone, he was always stationed on the right side of the political map. He became famous for many populist statements aimed at giving him the name of a tough right-wing man.

He offered to introduce a death law for terrorists. He offered to transfer to the Palestinian Authority territories within Israel where Arab citizens of Israel reside, thus making a transfer without moving them, but only by changing the borderline.

He arrogantly said that if he were to become Israel’s defense minister, he would provide an ultimatum to the Hamas leader and give him 48 hours to recover the bodies of Israeli soldiers or he would be eliminated. Not long after this threat, he was indeed appointed Minister of Defense, but the threat never came to fruition, which made him an example of a person whose word is meaningless among right-wing circles.

Avigdor Lieberman’s constituency, which forms his solid political base, is largely composed of Russian immigrants who immigrated to Israel in the early 1990s. Most of the immigrants from Russia have integrated well into the State of Israel and the younger generation is an integral part of Israeli society.

But still, there is a fairly large group of Russians, mostly older but not only, and these point to Avigdor Lieberman because of his Russian origin and the tough image he built for himself as a right-wing man, sort of the Israeli Putin. Apart from Avigdor Lieberman, there is no significant politician in the party and no one dares to defy him.

The members of his faction function as loyal loyal soldiers in spite of him. The party has no democratic mechanism for electing representatives for the Knesset. The candidates are selected by Lieberman, which of course has a great influence on how they conduct themselves.

From the moment Lieberman decides on a particular direction, even if it is in the opposite direction, his party members are quick to explain the new position, even if it is opposite to the position they explained a month earlier.

One of the most prominent features of Lieberman’s political conduct is impulsiveness and unpredictability. Lieberman resigned more than any other politician. As a matter of fact, it is very difficult to remember that Lieberman’s role played and ended normally. Lieberman usually completed his various duties ahead of time, in resignation.

Lieberman has never been “suspected” of being a clean-cut politician. On the contrary, he is considered one of the most corrupt politicians in the State of Israel. For 11 years (not continuous), he spent police investigations on various cases, though he was never prosecuted.

Several witnesses related to the investigations conducted against him have disappeared. Today, a trial is being held against one of his former party members, and there is a chance that a police investigation against Lieberman will open again.

First-round – Israel election results on April 2019

The right-wing bloc

Likud – 35

Shas – 8

Yahadut Ha’torah – 8

Unification of right-wing parties – 5

Israel Beitenu – 5

Kulanu – 4

The left-wing bloc

Blue and White – 35

Ha’avoda (Labor party) – 6

 Merez -4

The Arab bloc

Hadash – TA-AL – 6

Ra’am – Balad – 4

Total: 120 Knesset (parliament) members

First-round – election results (April 2019) interpretation

In the first election campaign in the current round that started the crisis, in April 2019, the rightist bloc clearly won and could easily form a government, just as it did in previous rounds. Together with Avigdor Lieberman, the right-wing parties had the necessary majority.

But here’s a sudden surprise. Lieberman went to Austria immediately after the election, and it was estimated that he met one of his sponsors, a man named Martin Schlaf, who is also associated with Yair Lapid, one of the leaders of the left-wing blue and white party.

Martin Schlaf’s name was found in a number of very serious corruption cases and in 2010, the police decided to prosecute him because of what he defined as “a serious corruption case investigated by the police, the transfer of millions of dollars to the Sharon family (Ariel Sharon, former prime minister). Only Sharon’s fall into a coma prevented Martin Schlaf’s trial.

In the same year (2003), the police opened another investigation, on suspicion that a company owned by Schlaf, transferred millions of shekels (Israel currency) to a Cypriot company controlled by Avigdor Lieberman. In December 2012, the case was closed for lack of evidence.

After returning to Israel (in April 2019 after the first round of elections), after meeting with Martin Schlaf, he refused to meet with Netanyahu and refused all references to him, and then again it became clear that Lieberman, the unexpected, is the most predictable.

For decades in politics, Lieberman was an ally of the ultra-Orthodox and cooperated with them regularly. Ironically, the mayor of Jerusalem was elected to office because of a political deal between Lieberman and the ultra-Orthodox. Suddenly, Lieberman turned his skin and began to act very aggressively against the ultra-Orthodox.

He conditional on joining the right-wing government on a non-principled and insignificant issue, the Ultra-Orthodox Recruitment Law (to the army). An issue that was not really on his political agenda before the election. Lieberman suddenly decided to insist on the spine of iodine and even when the ultra-Orthodox surrendered and agreed to all his capricious demands, Lieberman continued to insist and prevented the establishment of the government.

The 60 seats (out of 120 Knesset members) who were part in the Right-wing bloc (without Lieberman) were not enough to form a stable government, so the mandate was returned to the president and new elections scheduled for September 2019.

At that stage, Lieberman has begun to position himself politically as Israel’s liberal defender against the ultra-Orthodox “plotting to make it a religious state” and began a campaign of incitement against the ultra-Orthodox. Lieberman’s incitement campaign was conducted mainly in the Russian language, and of course turned to Russian immigrants, some of whom are not Jews.

Second round – Israel election results on September 2019

The right-wing bloc

Likud – 32

Shas – 9

Yahadut Ha’tora – 7

Yemina – 7

The left-wing bloc

Blue and White – 33

Ha’avoda (Labor party) – 6

Democratic Camp – 5

The Arab bloc

Ha’reshima Ha’meshutefet (Joined list) – 13

Outside the blocs

Israel Beitenu- 8

Second-round – election results (September 2019) interpretation

In September 2019, re-elections were held, which ended again with a result that did not allow a decision between the blocs. The results of the September 2019 elections created an impossible situation. Likud led by Benjamin Netanyahu had 55 Knesset members from all the parties who support the right-wing. It was the right-wing block. The Blue and White Party led by Benny Gantz had 44 seats. It was the left-wing block. The Arab party received 13 seats and Lieberman received 8 seats.

1. Netanyahu could not form a government without Lieberman.

2. Benny Gantz cannot form a government without the Arabs and without Lieberman.

The picture became very complicated due to a number of circumstances:

1. In the second round, Lieberman “forgot” about the recruitment law ( for the ultra-orthodox) that was the reason for the tangle in the first round and invented a new principle: a unity secular government or nothing, but still without a personal disqualification of Netanyahu.

2. The right-wing bloc (55 seats) was united around Benjamin Netanyahu’s leadership and was not ready to split in any way.

3. Almost all Arab party members (Ha’reshima Ha’meshutefet), actually support terrorism against the State of Israel and the elimination of the State of Israel as a Jewish state. Which makes it very difficult to collaborate with them even for leftists.

4. Avigdor Lieberman sees members of the Arab Knesset as a “fifth corps and part of the Arab enemy”, so he declared that he would not be part of a government they support even from the outside.

5. Within the Blue and White Party, there are three Knesset members who constitute the right-wing party in the list, who opposed any connection to the joint list.

6. Yair Lapid, Benny Gantz’s senior partner in the leadership of Blue and White, vehemently opposed the establishment of a unity government between the Likud and Blue-White, claiming that Netanyahu was suspected of bribery (this was before the decision to indict).

Publicly, the leaders of the big and small parties said the results of the election required a single government, but Blue-and-White leaders put two conditions into establishing such a government:

First condition: The Likud will dismantle the right-wing bloc and form a unity government together with the Blue and White Party, and other parties will be able to join later on the basis of this government.

Second condition: Benjamin Netanyahu will retire from the Likud and not lead the party because he is suspected of corruption offenses in three different cases (details below)

The purpose of both conditions was clear, breaking the right-wing bloc, weakening the Likud party and perhaps even dismantling and removing Benjamin Netanyahu, the undisputed leader of the Likud and the most popular leader among the Jewish public.

These will allow the left to return to power. The Blue-and-White work assumption was that if Netanyahu first gets the attempt to form the government, he will fail due to the lack of a 61, the failure to produce internal pressure in his right-wing bloc and inside the Likud, and lead parties from the right-wing bloc and Knesset members from the bloc to join the government of Blue-and-White.

What was not taken into account was the power of Netanyahu’s leadership within the right-wing bloc and his popularity among right-wing voters, which have failed the Blue and White Party’s plan and failed in its attempts to form a government.

After realizing that they would not be able to form a government, they debated among themselves whether to form a minority government based on the votes of the Arab party but following a veto by the right-wing faction in Blue-and-White, and following Lieberman’s unwillingness to enter such a government, the issue dropped out.

After his failure to assemble the government, Benny Gantz returned the mandate to the president of the state, and the mandate went to the Knesset for 21 days. Two days after Benny Gantz’s decision, the Attorney General decided to indict Benjamin Netanyahu on suspicion of bribery, fraud and breach of trust.

The indictment against Benjamin Netanyahu

Benjamin Netanyahu was persecuted by the Israeli media from the day he joined politics. Israeli media in the 1990s were completely identified with the left. Apart from a few isotropic cases, the media in the press, radio and television is dominated by the left.

Significant improvement has occurred in recent years but still, the right is insignificant lag. Benjamin Netanyahu has been a star ever since he began his political career as Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations and gave very impressive performances there. His father was a history professor.

His brother, Jonathan Netanyahu, was killed in one of the most famous operations in history: Operation Entebbe or Operation Jonathan (named for Benjamin Netanyahu’s brother) for the release of 105 Jewish passengers who were aboard an Air France hijacked in 1976 by German and Arab-Palestinian terrorists.

In 1988, Benjamin Netanyahu returned to Israel, joined the Likud party, and was elected to head it in 1993. The background of Benjamin Netanyahu Israel, his father who was a famous professor of history, his residence in one of Jerusalem’s most prestigious neighborhoods, service in the IDF’s finest unit, academic education at MIT, one of the world’s best universities, fluent English, performances in excellence and natural charisma. Make it part of the elite of the State of Israel.

But his choice to join the right has made him a target for the left since his political start. Countless investigations have been carried out on and around him in order to find something that can bring him down. During his political career, he fell and rose again in 2009 when he returned to become prime minister for the second time.

Since then, Netanyahu has been in power continuously until today (2020). He was credited with major successes in Israel’s economic and foreign relations sphere. Although he served in parallel to Barack Obama’s two presidencies, who was the most hostile president of the United States, Benjamin Netanyahu succeeded in curbing attempts to establish an Arab (Palestinian) state in Judea and Samaria and at the same time established Israel’s political position worldwide and in East and South Asia in particular.

Netanyahu’s strategy focused on developing and strengthening the Israeli economy and, consequently, strengthening its military and political power. This strategy was based on a profound and comprehensive worldview that sees the State of Israel as the home of the Jewish people, without causing the right of non-Jews in the State of Israel to live in equality and security, which actually occurs.

The results of Netanyahu’s policies have proved the failure of the left’s political and economic outlook. The Israeli left, followed by the European and American left-wing, used to threaten the world to boycott Israel (and some Jewish leftist organizations worked hard to promote boycotts and actions against the State of Israel).

They warned that the State of Israel would pay a heavy price if it did not agree to establish an Arab state in Judea and Samaria, but in practice, Netanyahu proved just the opposite. Although Netanyahu made no progress toward the dangerous solution of an Islamic Arab state (in addition to the 56 existing ones) in Judea, Israel still continued to break records every year.

Inbound tourism broke records every year (until the appearance of the Coronavirus). Netanyahu’s foreign policy has been a resounding success. Benjamin Netanyahu has become one of the most powerful and influential leaders in the world.

Benjamin Netanyahu has transformed the small state of Israel into one that many countries in the world are repurposing for its technological, economic and political power. But Netanyahu not only satisfied himself with this but continued to fortify the Jewish character of the State of Israel and promoted it through a number of laws, most notably the National Law, a basic law that defines the State of Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people.

Netanyahu’s successes, his immense popularity among an overwhelming majority of the Jewish people in Israel, and the demographics in Israel played to the right, turning the left into a hopeless player in the political arena. As the left weakened in the political arena, its political representatives and many left-wing organizations (funded through funds and foreign countries) moved the scene of the political confrontation to the Supreme Courts dominated by judges affiliated with the radical left.

The judicial system and the Supreme Court in Israel

Since the 1990s, the Israeli Supreme Court has undergone an unprecedented revolution. Supreme Court President Aharon Barak, a first-rate intellectual, led a revolution that changed the sacred balance between the three authorities: the judiciary, the legislature and the executive.

The judiciary began to churn out pieces of government and control itself over the legislature. In a long but very determined process, the judiciary made the laws meaningless and subjected them to what it called the “test of reasonableness and proportionality.”

That is, where the judgment of the Supreme Court is made on the basis of laws set by the legislature, that is, the Knesset, it is made on the basis of an abstract criterion of “reasonableness and “proportionality”, and these are determined by what the judge sees fit. That is, written law loses its meaning and together with it, Parliament loses its power as well.

And before them, the power of the Supreme Court is intensifying. In fact, a small oligarchic group, supported by media affiliated with the left, has actually taken over the decision-making apparatus in Israel and has turned itself into a government for allowing itself to intervene and rule on anything and everything, including foreign and security issues, according to its political view, without ever being elected and without assuming any responsibility.

Some of the results of their political ruling. The left-wing parties in Israel, of course, supported this because the entire empowerment of the Supreme Court allowed them to expand their power of control without being elected. In its legal rulings, the Supreme Court represented a radical leftist group that could not exercise its political doctrine because of a lack of a majority.

Thus, the democratic state of Israel has become a legal oligarchy. The tension between the two systems intensified. Even when there was a majority to the right, the right-wing government did not have a majority to pass laws limiting the power of the Supreme Court. There was always an incoming member who will position himself as “the protector of the law and the court” and thereby gain excessive media sympathy and legal immunity.

Legal immunity is required for the defense of the State Attorney’s Office. The State Prosecutor’s Office represents the State of Israel and the government authorities before the Israeli courts. The prosecutor’s office is part of the executive branch of the State of Israel, although it is an independent body.

The Office of the Attorney General in Israel is to strengthen the rule of law. The prosecutor’s office is the one who decides whether or not to prosecute public figures.

Over the years, the State Attorney’s Office has become a corrupt political entity, conducting selective enforcement against politicians who were the target. Usually, these were politicians who promised to restrain the judiciary or politicians from the right-wing. The prosecutor’s office, while boasting about the objections of objective lawmen, has turned the prosecution into an elimination syndicate of politicians they did not like.

All this took place with the backing of media personnel who provided media protection and public relations to the State Attorney’s Office, and in return received illegal leaks from investigations conducted by the State Prosecutor’s Office against politicians and public figures.

During his reign, Netanyahu chose not to confront and even backed the State Attorney’s office and the legal system. It is unclear whether this is because he knew that he did not have a majority anyway to make a change or because he chose to focus on the economic, security and political issues, or because he thought their work was nothing wrong.

Either way, a few years ago, according to the prosecutor’s office instructions, the police began a general investigation into Benjamin Netanyahu in an attempt to “fish” something. Gradually, while investing tremendous resources that are soon estimated at $ 100 million, the State Attorney’s Office began building four different affairs around Benjamin Netanyahu.

The various episodes were given names that created a numerical continuity in order to produce a semblance of a corruption sequence. Out of the four cases, three were left at last, and against Benjamin Netanyahu, he was indicted on the recommendation of the Israeli Attorney General, who had a key role in investigations, illegal leaks and the attempt to bring Netanyahu to trial.

This is not the place to elaborate on the various cases, but in general, it can be said that many in Israel and abroad, including some of the most senior lawyers in the United States, these cases did not have any criminal element. The impression was that the purpose of the investigations was to obtain through the court, what the Left parties did not achieve through elections: the removal of Netanyahu.

The legal assassinations brought by the prosecution have already shown that this is a practice that is not foreign to them. It was usually enough to file the indictment and cause the politician to retire. This was the case in the past. But in the case of Netanyahu, they encountered a hard nut to crack.

Not only did he not retire and spare them the need to go to court, but the opposite happened, his grip on the Likud party intensified and public support grew, proving complete and unprecedented and danger distrust of the Jewish public in Israel by the Israeli police and the State Attorney’s Office.

Third round – Israel election results on March 2020

Ahead of the third election campaign, primaries were held for Likud leadership. Benjamin Netanyahu won in a big gap and was once again crowned the undisputed leader of the Likud party. This time, the Likud campaign included many of Netanyahu’s performances in various cities around the country, as well as an Internet campaign, as was the case in the previous election campaigns.

Unlike the previous election campaigns, a number of things have happened. The most significant thing was that Avigdor Lieberman, who used to boast that “his word is a word,” changed direction for the third time.

For the first time, he prevented the establishment of the right-wing government under the pretext of the Ultra-Orthodox recruitment law. For the second time, his campaign was about a secular unity government. For the third time, his campaign became a personal campaign against Netanyahu.

Lieberman stated clearly that his goal is “to end the Netanyahu era.” In order to preserve his political base, Lieberman launched a Russian-speaking campaign, which has anti-Semitic features, which focused on inciting hatred against ultra-Orthodox Jews, the “parasites” that “rob us of the money.”

The Blue and White Party led a campaign that hated Netanyahu when it compared Turkish dictator Erdogan who massacred thousands of people in Turkey and Syria. Huge signs with Netanyahu’s picture were posted on the main roads, and on the signs read: “Blue or Erdogan”.

The Likud ran a campaign that focused on the distinct and obvious weaknesses of Benny Gantz, the party’s candidate for prime minister. Following dozens of filmed and documented cases in which Benny Gantz was mistaken, he became confused at the trial, said unclear sentences, forgot what he wanted to say while he spoke, mistook people’s names, the impression began to emerge.

That Benny Gantz has some problems. On one of the occasions Netanyahu specifically addressed this issue and aroused Benny Gantz. In addition, during the campaign, there were a number of harsh exposures about Benny Gantz.

The first exposure was that of an independent journalist. According to what he published, it turned out that the Iranians had broken into Benny Gantz’s phone (it was already known in the first election campaign), and brought out extremely embarrassing material, Including Benny Gantz’s abrasive films, which he sent to his mistress in the United States. Gantz threatened with libel but did not file it.

The second exposure was about his involvement in the alleged illegal cases. According to the report, Benny Gantz, who after his military service, was the chairman of a technology company, illegally won a government tender, following ties with the police chief.

The company he ran and led eventually went bankrupt. Despite the suspicions against Benny Gantz, the prosecutor’s office dissolved the case and refrained from instructing the police to open an investigation, apparently, so as not to prejudice Benny Gantz’s chances in the election.

The third exposure was a recording of his strategic adviser, who said he was “a danger to Israel’s security,” said Benny Gantz “had a relationship of authority with one of his female subordinates” and called it “a pit of impurity.” The results of the third election also ended in a tangle, although this time the Likud became the largest party, and the entire right-wing bloc won 58 seats in the Knesset.

The third election results – March 2020

The right block

The Likud – 36

Shas – 9

Yahadut Ha’torah – 7

Yemina – 6 seats

The left block

Blue and White – 33

Labor – Meretz – 7

The Arabs

Ha’reshima Ha’meshutefet – 15

Outside the blocs

Israel Beitenu – 7

The political options followed the third election results

Historically, the main conflict was between the right and the left and the Arabs were generally out of bounds as far as establishing a government was concerned. The reason for this was the identification of the elected representatives of the Arab public with Arab terror, with terrorist organizations such as the PLO, Hezbollah and Hamas and their support for the elimination of the State of Israel as a Jewish state.

There is probably not one representative on this list who did not support terrorism in any way, direct or indirect. The platform of the Ha’reshima Ha’meshutefet, includes a series of requirements that are no less than the elimination of the State of Israel.

The official state of Israel invests quite a bit in the Arab public, which enjoys equal rights, many rights and very few obligations (they are exempt from military service while young Jews are required to have a regular three-year military, and women are obliged for two years).

The various governments have almost always avoided direct reliance on their elected political representatives, due to the extremism that characterized them. For the first time this happened in 1992 when the left bloc led by Yitzhak Rabin won 56 seats, the Arabs won 5 seats, and together they had 61 seats (out of a total of 120 Knesset members in the Israeli parliament), which constituted a majority and withheld from the right the ability to form a government.

Rabin succeeded in attaching the ultra-Orthodox Shas party to his government and was supported by the votes of Arab members of the Knesset from outside, without having entered his government. Later, the Shas party resigned from the Rabin government, the Rabin government became a minority government that relied on the votes of the Arab Knesset members who gave it the necessary majority.

At no point did they enter the government. At this stage, however, when the State of Israel is about to go for a fourth election campaign, Blue and White decided to form a government based on the artificial majority, which consists of a mathematical majority of 62 seats that is more than 58 seats in the Knesset, but it is devoid of any ideological connection.

This is a majority that consists of parties that despise one another and are only connected with one issue, which hates Netanyahu and wants to exclude him from Israeli politics.

error

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)

Scroll to Top